Through blogs and comments, patients and experts explore what it takes to find good health care and make the most of it.

Watched, Loved and Now Desired by Millions


If popular culture provides clues to social trends then all signs point to an American public captivated by red velvet, carrot, lemon, and raspberry.  Fabric, fruits and vegetables? No cakes whether of the cup variety or fancy full-size versions.

Special occasions that call for a special cake--which once signified a wedding'have expanded to any gathering of more than one person. Showers, going-away, divorce, engagement, new home, graduations, anniversary, lost a job: there seems to be no event that should not be celebrated with an extreme cake or two. Homemade cakes seen in those faded photos of baby boomer's childhood birthdays are completely unacceptable and passé. No child of today is too young for custom creations of flour, sugar and butter.

In this case the egg certainly precedes the chicken. But is the egg the growing line-up of baking shows and stars on TV? Elaborate over-the-top cake design competitions and daily life in the kitchens of small bakeries have become ubiquitous in prime-time.

One new reality show, DC Cupcakes, manages to blend the current obsession with small overpriced sugary treats with dropping out of the corporate world and finding $$$, happiness and creative fulfillment. And in a Tidewater VA newspaper this weekend, I read of a woman who was finding her way out of losing her job, home and car by opening a cake business out of a small rental house kitchen.

While I applaud the entrepreneurial incentives and hard work that is reflected in these examples I am stunned that so many people are ordering and eating cakes of whatever size. One show Ace of Cakes filmed in nearby Baltimore, doesn't even pretend that it is the taste of the cake that drives the hefty price tag instead it seems to be all about the uber-personalized designs as in detailed replicas of Yankee Stadium, 65 Mustang convertibles, or a pet basset hound.

Where dietitians and public health experts once worried primarily about the influence of TV advertising on eating habits and norms, the amazing popularity of food TV suggests that those billion-dollar food-advertising budgets may not be necessary. And for some reason, we currently seem to be particularly enthralled with cake, completely empty calories and outrageously expensive ones too.

What is it about this storyline that seems to be catching (or is it reflecting) the public the tough economic climate making butter cream, fondant and personalized confections our favorite new refuge?  I thought I understood the attractions of comfort food because I associate foods like mac & cheese, meatloaf, chicken pot pie with brief retreats back to what seemed to be a simpler life'mom in the kitchen, TV dinners in the 60's or diner food'cheap, filling and retro. But I confess that I am mystified by this new trend towards pastry as the star of every party or worth standing in 45-minute lines.

Can a nutritionist in our pocket and Michelle Obama's Let's Move campaign really hope to compete with cake celebrities and what appears to be a national craving for a sugar buzz?

More Blog Posts by Dorothy Jeffress

author bio

Dorothy Jeffress, MBA, MSW, MA, ( executive director, joined CFAH in March 2008. Prior positions include vice president, Center for Information Therapy, 2005-2008, where she assisted with the IxAction Alliance membership program, the annual Ix Conference and finance/administration for the IxCenter; and as the assistant vice president of Value Based Purchasing for the National Business Coalition on Health (NBCH) from 2003 to 2005, where she directed the eValue8 Request for Information (RFI) program. She also worked with NCQA from 1999 to 2002 where she was the director of constituent relations and a senior health care analyst in HEDIS performance measure development. She has also worked for the Massachusetts Department of Public Health as the director of a CDC/state-funded women's health promotion and chronic disease prevention program. She has managed a TPA for self-funded employee benefit programs and also been a benefit manager for a mid-sized employer. Dorothy has an MBA from Clemson University and an MSW in clinical social work and an MA in theology from Boston College.

Tags for this article:
Diet and Nutrition   Exercise/Physical Activity   Dorothy Jeffress   Promote your Health   Lifestyle and Prevention  

Comments on this post
Please note: CFAH reserves the right to moderate all comments posted to the Prepared Patient® Blog. Any inappropriate postings will be removed.

Sarah Jorgenson says
July 21, 2010 at 1:48 PM

My boyfriend and I were always intrigued by a cupcake store by his old apartment in Chicago. The cupcakes lined the window and were absolutely beautiful. We walked past the store everyday, and finally, we caved in. We had to try one. We got some fancy decorated one with frosting piled so high that you could barely see the cake part of the cupcake. It cost over five dollars, and it was the greatest let down ever. It turns out the cupcakes should stay in the display window.

Though I donâ??t know much about Ace of Cakes, I am not surprised with Americaâ??s or other countriesâ?? fascination with it and shows that are similar. It is junk food television, shows that you know you shouldnâ??t waste time watching but it takes every ounce of determination not to. The larger impact on society is that these shows have the potential to influence unhealthy eating habits. And they have! It is one more obstacle to overcome in trying to create a healthier society. Though, I wouldn't encourage the elimination of them. They are entertaining!