Through blogs and comments, patients and experts explore what it takes to find good health care and make the most of it.

Where, Oh Where Are Those Insurance Summaries for Consumers?


article image
Follow us on Facebook

Buying health insurance through the state shopping exchanges was supposed to be a breeze — like buying an airline ticket from Travelocity. But it isn't, and the reason why has nothing to do with the technical glitches of It has everything to do with health insurance itself, a complicated product most Americans have little experience buying. They have little experience because most get their coverage from employers' health plans, Medicare or Medicaid, all of which make most of the coverage decisions.

The designers of the Affordable Care Act knew they were asking consumers who would be eligible to buy insurance through an exchange to take on a tough task. To help them out, the law called for a consumer disclosure document that would allow apples-to-apples comparisons among insurance policies. Consumer advocates and insurance regulators spent months compromising and crafting a tool they thought would work. Enter the document called the Summary of Benefits and Coverage.

The advocates and regulators did a good job. For each policy a shopper considers, the summary of benefits document discloses the deductible, out-of-pocket maximums, co-pays and coinsurance. That's the percentage of a bill consumers must pay, and it can add up to a lot if they get sick. Because the slick marketing brochures insurance carriers hand out usually don't give the full story when it comes to coinsurance — that is, what services it applies to, and how it can vary if you use providers outside the insurer's network — the disclosure summary goes much further. Companies must now tell customers exactly what services are subject to a coinsurance amount.

Insurers are slapping high coinsurance on the most commonly used services like X-rays and diagnostic imaging, laboratory services, hospital outpatient care and treatment at urgent care centers. What consumers have to pay out-of-pocket for those services is a key variable when comparison shopping. The summary of benefits, which explains why these variables matter, also shows what certain illnesses like breast cancer and maternity care might cost someone who buys this policy.

When shoppers put these summaries side-by-side, it becomes clearer which policy is best for particular consumers given their tolerance for risk and trade-offs. For example, someone who wants to pay less up front with a low premium needs to know they are likely to pay high cost-sharing when they get sick.

There's one shortcoming. The law didn't require the summary to disclose the premium. It was assumed shoppers would find that out on their own. Still, because the coverage information has to be given in a uniform way by each carrier, these summaries have the potential to be a valuable piece of consumer information. The big hitch: Few consumers know about them.

In the drama over affordability and cheap premiums, these benefit summaries have gotten lost. Insurers are not required to give them. If a consumer asks for them, insurers must provide the documents, but how many know to ask? Some insurers may not go out of their way to make them available. Instead they present fragments of important information that may leave out crucial details.

I saw how useful these summaries of benefits documents can be. CoOpportunity Health, one of those new co-op insurance companies that will be operating in some states, presented one to a Nebraska woman who has been shopping for an exchange policy. The specs for each of the company's policies were presented on one page. She could quickly see that silver plans came with 30 percent coinsurance for laboratory services and gold plans came with 20. But because the premiums were given as a range, it was hard to make an actual comparison from this table alone.

The woman also looked at information from Blue Cross. There was a summary sheet, but it seemed less specific. For example, it didn't say what the coinsurance was for lab services. A more detailed description was supposed to be in another document. I didn't see it there either. I found it in a third document that I had to print from the website.

My takeaway based on this very limited sample: The summary of benefits and coverage information may be somewhere in all the materials a company provides. But it's still hard to wade through it and it appears to be far from uniform. As soon as the government fixes, perhaps its next task should be to investigate whether the carriers selling on the exchanges are making it easy or hard for consumers to obtain vital information about exactly what they are buying.

More Blog Posts by Trudy Lieberman

author bio

Trudy Lieberman, a journalist for more than 40 years, is an adjunct associate professor of public health at Hunter College in New York City. She had a long career at Consumer Reports specializing in insurance, health care, health care financing and long-term care. She is a longtime contributor to the Columbia Journalism Review and blogs for its website,, about media coverage of health care, Social Security and retirement. As a William Ziff Fellow at the Center for Advancing Health, she contributes regularly to the Prepared Patient Blog. Follow her on twitter @Trudy_Lieberman.

Tags for this article:
Health Insurance   Medicare/Medicaid   Trudy Lieberman   Health Care Cost   Pay for your Health Care  

Comments on this post
Please note: CFAH reserves the right to moderate all comments posted to the Prepared Patient® Blog. Any inappropriate postings will be removed.

Lynn Canatella says
December 9, 2013 at 2:42 PM

I've been trying to fly through Blue Cross. This is after spending 10 weeks piecing together bits and pieces of information , none of which came from Even more important than the plan summary is the actual plan documents. All of the links I found for the gold plans that were supposed to lead you to the full plan documents were in active. The salesperson and then subsequently sales people I spoke to the promised to send me active links or the actual documents For the formularies as well as the gold policies. I have never received them. I believe know that when somebody is asking that level of detailed questions that they obviously have an illness and that they are not interested in helping. I have breast cancer. So nine weeks into the shopping process , 20 days before my PCIP coverage expires I still don't know which is the best plan for me because I cannot get complete disclosure from either or directly through the insurance companies. The whole thing is a sham,