January
4, 2005
|
Vol.
8 No. 1
|
NAS REPORT: NOT ENOUGH DATA ON GUN VIOLENCE
Studies of firearms and gun violence in the United States are so weak
that researchers can not say for sure whether concealed weapon laws lead
to more or less crime, whether suicides are more likely where guns are
more readily available or whether programs to steer kids away from gun
violence have any effect on their behavior, according to a report issued
by the National Academies' National Research Council on Dec. 16, 2004.
Although there are an
increasing number of studies of gun violence and patterns of firearm
use, a lack of data remains “at the
heart of many of the difficulties in advancing research in this area,” said
the report’s lead author, Charles Wellford, Ph.D., of the University
of Maryland, College Park.
“I think it’s a fair conclusion to argue that our first
investment should be in research to see if we can improve data on
firearms violence, ownership, access and possession, and if that’s
achieved, then we’ll be in a better position to start addressing
some of these other research questions,” Wellford said.
The report calls for federal
government support of a “systematic
program of data collection and research that specifically addresses” firearms
violence. The report authors also recommend continued support for
two existing databases, the National Violent Death Reporting System
and National Incident-Based Reporting System.
Wellford and the others
acknowledge that collecting information on guns will be difficult
in the face of Americans’ “deeply
held concerns” about privacy and potential uses of a government
firearms database. Eventually, gun data would be combined with other
political considerations to determine specific policy recommendations,
the authors conclude.
“Should regulations restrict who may possess firearms? Should
there be restrictions on the number or types of guns that can be
purchased? Should safety locks be required? Answers to these questions
involve issues that go beyond research on firearm violence,” said
Wellford.
To read the full report, “Firearms and Violence: A Critical
Review,” go here.