|
July 22,
2003 CONFLICTED
SCIENCE’ IN
WASHINGTON, D.C.
Two-thirds of Americans believe that science is driven by the financial
interests of business and industry, according to a new poll commissioned
by the consumer advocacy group Center for Science in the Public Interest. The poll suggests that people are especially wary of gifts that drug
companies give to doctors: 64 percent think that the medical judgment
of physicians can be swayed by these gifts. Michael F. Jacobsen,
CSPI executive director, called the gifts “a
prescription for inferior medical care” and said that “the
public’s perception suggests a crisis of confidence in the medical
community.” The poll’s message hovered in the background of CSPI’s July
11 meeting on “conflicted science,” where researchers, journalists
and a handful of industry representatives came to debate whether corporate
money in science does more harm than good. Drummond Rennie, M.D., deputy editor of the Journal of the American
Medical Association, was one of several speakers who concluded that complete
separation of public and private funding for research is the only way
to keep research free of corporate bias. “Dependence on corporate money corrupts institutions, researchers
and [doctors],” he said. Researchers and journalists also squared off on the question of how
much space the media should give to reporting the potential conflicts
of interest among the researchers they cover. Nearly two-thirds of people
polled by CSPI say that reporters should include information on whether
university scientists quoted in their articles receive money from companies
with a financial stake in the research. New York Times science editor Cornelia Dean said that reporters do their
best to include conflict-of-interest information when it appears relevant
to the story, but that journalists risk cutting back on the newsworthy
elements of a story if disclosure is made a standard rule for every article. To read more about
CSPI’s
Integrity in Science program, go to http://cspinet.org/integrity/.
|
|
||||||